“For the Israeli hostages being held incommunicado in Gaza under the most horrific conditions, the ICJ’s ruling is tantamount to a death sentence, or at the very least an indefinite prolongation of their agony.
“For the people of Israel, the ICJ has decreed that they must live under the perpetual shadow of terrorism and genocide. For the people of Gaza, the ICJ offers only the dismal prospect of a reinstatement of Hamas’s tyranny and the degradation, brutality, poverty and fear that are its bitter fruits.
“For the world at large, the ICJ has dealt a devastating blow to international law and the system that was so carefully constructed after World War II to preserve international peace and security, and risks a breakdown in that system and a reversion to international anarchy and bloodshed.
“Israel has taken more precautions than any other country fighting a war in an urban setting to avoid harm to civilians. But there is no gentle way of dealing with the butchers and rapists of Hamas. Their capacity for murder and mayhem needs to be destroyed, root and branch. No democratic country faced with similar circumstances would disempower itself in the face of terrorists, or should call on Israel to do so.”
Executive Council of Australian Jewry comment on recent ICJ decision
Executive Council of Australian Jewry comment on recent ICJ decision
To download this statement, please click here.
“For the Israeli hostages being held incommunicado in Gaza under the most horrific conditions, the ICJ’s ruling is tantamount to a death sentence, or at the very least an indefinite prolongation of their agony.
“For the people of Israel, the ICJ has decreed that they must live under the perpetual shadow of terrorism and genocide. For the people of Gaza, the ICJ offers only the dismal prospect of a reinstatement of Hamas’s tyranny and the degradation, brutality, poverty and fear that are its bitter fruits.
“For the world at large, the ICJ has dealt a devastating blow to international law and the system that was so carefully constructed after World War II to preserve international peace and security, and risks a breakdown in that system and a reversion to international anarchy and bloodshed.
“Israel has taken more precautions than any other country fighting a war in an urban setting to avoid harm to civilians. But there is no gentle way of dealing with the butchers and rapists of Hamas. Their capacity for murder and mayhem needs to be destroyed, root and branch. No democratic country faced with similar circumstances would disempower itself in the face of terrorists, or should call on Israel to do so.”
Latest
Antisemitism is becoming harder to recognise in the West
Commentary by co-CEO Peter Wertheim, originally published in the Australian Financial Review on 7 April 2026.
Israel death penalty law
ECAJ statement on Israel's new death penalty law.
Outrage at heinous attack on UK Jewish community ambulances
J7 statement on the attack on Hatzolah ambulances in Golders Green, London.
ECAJ: “gross antisemitism” in David Rowe cartoon
Letter to the Australian Financial Review editor about the David Rowe cartoon containing antisemitic tropes.