This opinion piece by ECAJ co-CEO Alex Ryvchin was originally published in the Daily Telegraph.
My inclusion in the Russian Government’s list of Australians sanctioned for “formulating the anti-Russia agenda” will not change my support for Ukraine, my deep affection for the wonderful Ukrainian-Australian community, or my revulsion at the illegal and inhuman war.
The invasion of Ukraine launched on 24 February 2022 revived the worst instincts of Soviet-Russian despotism. The defining characteristic of Russian leadership in both Soviet and Imperial times was a savage disregard for human life. Indeed, one of the architects of the Bolshevik Revolution, Leonid Trotsky proclaimed that “we must put an end, once and for all, to the Papist-Quaker babble about the sanctity of human life.”
Russian communism took human disposal to new heights. Half a million Soviet citizens bled out in the Finnish snow in the doomed winter war of 1939. Millions were hauled off to servitude building infrastructure as slave labourers, living out their lives in squalor at the behest of the people’s government. 300,000 died building the Trans-Siberian Railway alone. Killing quotas during collectivisation, show trials, blood-spattered confessions, the deliberate appointment of psychopaths like Yezhov, Yagoda and Beria to positions of immense power.
The staggering death rate of Soviet soldiers in the two world wars is not a testament to national pride or noble sacrifice but to criminal culpability of its leaders. There is no honour in running at enemy positions unarmed, waiting for a comrade to be struck down before picking up his weapon or of charging at machine-guns with farming implements.
There is another Russia though, which is why my sanctioning means something to me. There is a Russia of exquisite literature and music. A beautiful language that is my mother-tongue. A cuisine that invokes all the soul and depth of a tormented history. A people for whom I harbour absolutely no ill-feeling. A country that scores of my relatives volunteered to defend against the fascist invaders. An army that stalled and turned back the Nazi killing machine and whose men were the first to open the gates of Auschwitz.
This is one of the great tragedies of Putin’s war. The corruption of the history of the Great Patriotic War by shamefully equating the Nazis with modern Ukraine. But the greatest tragedy is that inflicted on the people of Ukraine.
Decrying this scandalous war, lending our voices to the Ukrainian nation and its suffering diaspora is the bare minimum we can do. Ukraine will prevail because its cause is just, and it soldiers fights to preserve a homeland that is rightfully theirs rather than to subjugate another people. Glory to Ukraine and let the sanctions fall where they may.
Sanctioned by Russia – A story of sorrow and pride
Sanctioned by Russia – A story of sorrow and pride
This opinion piece by ECAJ co-CEO Alex Ryvchin was originally published in the Daily Telegraph.
My inclusion in the Russian Government’s list of Australians sanctioned for “formulating the anti-Russia agenda” will not change my support for Ukraine, my deep affection for the wonderful Ukrainian-Australian community, or my revulsion at the illegal and inhuman war.
The invasion of Ukraine launched on 24 February 2022 revived the worst instincts of Soviet-Russian despotism. The defining characteristic of Russian leadership in both Soviet and Imperial times was a savage disregard for human life. Indeed, one of the architects of the Bolshevik Revolution, Leonid Trotsky proclaimed that “we must put an end, once and for all, to the Papist-Quaker babble about the sanctity of human life.”
Russian communism took human disposal to new heights. Half a million Soviet citizens bled out in the Finnish snow in the doomed winter war of 1939. Millions were hauled off to servitude building infrastructure as slave labourers, living out their lives in squalor at the behest of the people’s government. 300,000 died building the Trans-Siberian Railway alone. Killing quotas during collectivisation, show trials, blood-spattered confessions, the deliberate appointment of psychopaths like Yezhov, Yagoda and Beria to positions of immense power.
The staggering death rate of Soviet soldiers in the two world wars is not a testament to national pride or noble sacrifice but to criminal culpability of its leaders. There is no honour in running at enemy positions unarmed, waiting for a comrade to be struck down before picking up his weapon or of charging at machine-guns with farming implements.
There is another Russia though, which is why my sanctioning means something to me. There is a Russia of exquisite literature and music. A beautiful language that is my mother-tongue. A cuisine that invokes all the soul and depth of a tormented history. A people for whom I harbour absolutely no ill-feeling. A country that scores of my relatives volunteered to defend against the fascist invaders. An army that stalled and turned back the Nazi killing machine and whose men were the first to open the gates of Auschwitz.
This is one of the great tragedies of Putin’s war. The corruption of the history of the Great Patriotic War by shamefully equating the Nazis with modern Ukraine. But the greatest tragedy is that inflicted on the people of Ukraine.
Decrying this scandalous war, lending our voices to the Ukrainian nation and its suffering diaspora is the bare minimum we can do. Ukraine will prevail because its cause is just, and it soldiers fights to preserve a homeland that is rightfully theirs rather than to subjugate another people. Glory to Ukraine and let the sanctions fall where they may.
Latest
Still reeling three years on
ECAJ Head of Content Zeddy Lawrence reflects on the upcoming third anniversary of 7 October in The Australian Jewish News.
October 7 – Third Anniversary Commemorations
Official events marking the third anniversary of the Hamas attack which saw over 1,200 people slaughtered and more than 250 people taken hostage
Remembering Babi Yar 85 years on
'People walk atop the ash and bones of our sacred dead oblivious to the horrors that transpired there just a few generations ago.'
Responding to reported deicide charge
'The attribution of collective guilt to the Jewish people ... remains one of the clearest distinguishing markers of the disgrace of antisemitism'