US’s Gaza plan a display in the politics of power

US’s Gaza plan a display in the politics of power

Commentary from co-CEO Alex Ryvchin originally published in The Australian on 1 October 2025.

The sin­gle most impor­tant qual­i­ty of a polit­i­cal sur­vivor is the abil­i­ty to detect where true pow­er lies. Israeli Prime Min­is­ter Ben­jamin Netanyahu has seen his world shrink. Tra­di­tion­al­ly friend­ly gov­ern­ments lined up to recog­nise a Pales­tin­ian state. The con­temp­tu­ous response of much of the inter­na­tion­al com­mu­ni­ty to his speech at the Gen­er­al Assem­bly.

Netanyahu was able to brush this all aside and parse that the future of his nation and his own lega­cy will not be deter­mined in Can­ber­ra or in declin­ing Euro­pean pow­ers led by lame duck lead­ers, it will be set­tled in Wash­ing­ton, Riyadh and Doha. Netanyahu wasn’t talk­ing to the UN or its ane­mic mem­ber states. He was talk­ing to his own base and to the White House.

The joint press con­fer­ence by the two lead­ers, at which the US pro­pos­al to end the war was unveiled, showed that Netanyahu retains the con­fi­dence and sup­port of Pres­i­dent Trump. Pres­i­dent Trump in turn exerts an emperor’s pow­er over the inter­na­tion­al com­mu­ni­ty, par­tic­u­lar­ly those parts of it whose poli­cies are dri­ven by a desire for progress and wealth and not by street rab­ble, online influ­encers and aca­d­e­mics clad in cor­duroy.

And so, as some states, in their desire to project rel­e­vance and pres­tige, moved to recog­nise a Pales­tin­ian state which isn’t there, the Trump admin­is­tra­tion craft­ed a pro­pos­al to actu­al­ly end this war. A plan that unlike uni­lat­er­al recog­ni­tion, can achieve the things our gov­ern­ment says it cares about – lib­er­a­tion of the hostages, an end to civil­ian suf­fer­ing, a future with­out Hamas, the de-rad­i­cal­i­sa­tion of Gaza and its peace­ful recon­struc­tion for its peo­ple. In oth­er words, true last­ing peace and gen­uine coex­is­tence rather than tem­po­rary cease­fires to allow the domes­tic polit­i­cal flak for west­ern lead­ers to briefly set­tle, or idle joint let­ters that try to say every­thing but say noth­ing at all.

Israel has accept­ed the pro­pos­al which will oblig­ate it to per­ma­nent­ly end its mil­i­tary cam­paign in Gaza, and to release thou­sands of Pales­tin­ian ter­ror­ists and fight­ers it cur­rent­ly holds. The gov­ern­ments of the major play­ers in the Islam­ic and Arab world, includ­ing Sau­di Ara­bia, Pak­istan, Qatar, Turkey and Indone­sia, have also backed it.

The ques­tion is what will Hamas do? And what will our gov­ern­ment, that has insin­u­at­ed itself into the con­flict through its recog­ni­tion procla­ma­tion, do to ensure this com­pre­hen­sive peace plan becomes a real­i­ty? Aus­tralia has shown a will­ing­ness to pun­ish Israel in a great num­ber of ways for what it sees as its intran­si­gence, what will it do to ensure the Pales­tini­ans uphold their side of the bar­gain?

For starters, our gov­ern­ment can’t sim­ply say it endors­es this peace plan, it needs to work with the UK, Cana­da and France in apply­ing max­i­mum pres­sure on all Pales­tin­ian fac­tions to accept and imple­ment it with­out delay.

If this plan suc­ceeds, Netanyahu’s stock as a polit­i­cal sur­vivor will enter new stratos­pheres. But if it fails despite the will of the Unit­ed States, Israel and the Islam­ic world, it will reveal a ter­ri­fy­ing truth – the course of war and con­flict, and all the mis­ery it entails, is deter­mined not by the peace­mak­ers but by ter­ror­ists and rogues, and all our inter­ven­tions are for naught. If this is revealed to be so, the total destruc­tion of Hamas, will be the only option.

Help us improve

Thanks for visting our website today. Can you spare a minute to give us feedback on our website? We're always looking for ways to improve our site.

Did you find what you came here for today?
How likely are you to recommend this website to a friend or colleague? On a scale from 0 (least likely) to 10 (most likely).
0 is least likely; 10 is most likely.
Subscribe pop-up tile

Stay up to date with a weekly newsletter and breaking news updates from the ECAJ, the voice of the Australian Jewish community.

Name